All Articles

Why Cybernetics "Dissolved"

Institutionally dead and conceptually everywhere. Six reasons the field lost its name while its ideas spread.

The Editors

In the 1950s cybernetics was one of the most talked-about sciences in the world. By the 1980s most people met the word only as a prefix in science fiction. What happened? It is a question worth sitting with, because the answer has lessons for any field.

The short answer is that cybernetics lost its institutions while its ideas won. A Cybcom correspondent, quoting the systems scientist Charles François, put it in a Spanish proverb: “Los muertos que vos matáis gozan de buena salud” (the dead you kill are in good health).

1. No department of its own

Universities hire, teach, and fund by subject. Cybernetics claimed relevance to every subject and had no particular object of its own, which is a wonderful thing for ideas and a terrible thing for careers. When its founders retired or died, there were few posts to pass on. The Biological Computer Laboratory in Illinois, its main American home, closed in the mid-1970s when von Foerster retired and funding dried up.

2. The money moved to AI

From 1956, artificial intelligence offered funders a clearer programme: symbolic reasoning on digital computers, with concrete milestones. The US Advanced Research Projects Agency put large sums into AI labs. The Mansfield Amendment (1969) then required military research funding to have direct military relevance, which made the broad, basic research that cybernetics relied on harder to justify.

3. Its founders split

Norbert Wiener broke with Warren McCulloch’s group in the early 1950s for personal reasons, splitting the field’s two main American centres. Wiener’s public refusal of military work also distanced its most famous voice from its largest funder. Walter Pitts withdrew from science. John von Neumann died in 1957.

4. Its success scattered it

Feedback, information, and self-organisation proved so useful that other fields took them over. Control engineering, computer science, cognitive science, operations research, ecology, management science, and family therapy each kept the parts they needed. N. Katherine Hayles describes this as cybernetics succeeding by disappearing: the concepts survived, the name did not.

5. The second-order turn

From the 1970s, a large part of the community turned to epistemology: how observers construct knowledge. The historian Ronald Kline links the arrival of the term “second-order cybernetics” with the end of the field’s moment in American science. These questions were important, but they were hard to fund, hard to test, and easy for engineers to dismiss as philosophy.

6. Vocabulary and culture

Cybernetics developed a dense private language: variety, algedonic, metasystem, autopoiesis, structural coupling. Outsiders often heard jargon. In the Cybcom archive, Shann Turnbull observed that Stafford Beer’s followers used different words for concepts social scientists already had. Other correspondents worried that the community spent too much time telling stories about its founders and too little producing textbooks and courses that would carry its ideas to newcomers.

Did it actually dissolve?

It depends where you look.

  • In the US, institutionally, yes, by the mid-1970s.
  • In Europe, it persisted in management cybernetics, systems departments, and journals such as Kybernetes.
  • In Latin America, the legacies of Maturana, Varela, and Cybersyn kept it culturally alive.
  • In the USSR and China, it was absorbed into state science and planning, and lived on there.
  • Conceptually, it is everywhere: in machine learning, climate models, neuroscience, and the design of digital platforms.

The revival

Since the 2010s there are clear signs of return: new histories, the ANU School of Cybernetics, an active speaker series at the American Society for Cybernetics, the open-access journal Enacting Cybernetics, and growing interest from people working on AI. Much of this interest comes from a sense that the systems now shaping society are feedback systems, and that the field which studied feedback most carefully has something to say about them.

Further reading

  • Ronald Kline, The Cybernetics Moment (2015)
  • Andrew Pickering, The Cybernetic Brain (2010)
  • N. Katherine Hayles, How We Became Posthuman (1999)
Back to all articles

Type to search articles and the wiki.